Trump’s Legacy – Half a Million Americans Die of Covid-19 on His Watch

Before noon on January 20th, President Trump will leave his office.  At that time the reported death toll from COVID-19 in the USA will be over 400,000 – the exact number depending on who does the tallying.  Worldmeter will show 412k – real-time, Johns Hopkins will show 402k – lagging by a day, and CDC will show lower – lagging by a couple of days.  All these estimates understate the real toll history will attribute to Trump - over 500k Americans died on his watch.    

COVID-19 death reporting has time lags and other issues.

1.     Accurately assigning the correct cause of death is sometimes more art than science.  There are the underlying cause and the proximate cause issue.  Sometimes COVID-19 starts a chain of events that lead to death many months later from lung, heart, kidney, liver, or diabetes problems that are not uniquely attributable to COVID-19.  The US CDC separately defines confirmed and probable counts and reports both now.  A confirmed case or death is defined by matching confirmatory laboratory evidence for COVID-19.  A probably case is more loosely defined but is now included by most states reporting to the CDC.  There is no time limitation.  (Other countries use different definitions that sometimes make comparisons across jurisdictions difficult.)

2.     Excess deaths, or deaths above normal average year expectations, often exceed the reported COVID-19 deaths implying that undercounting of COVID-19 deaths may be occurring using the direct method.  As of Oct. 15th when reported deaths were 216k, CDC estimated excess death near 299k – 42% more.  

3.     Reported deaths sometimes occur more than a month after the actual date of death  Currently, 60% of all US deaths are reported within 10 days of death but some state (like Florida) and many countries can take more than 2 months to be just 75% complete.   

Our models for the COVID-19 virus infection and death are based on curves that rise quickly after exposure, peak, and then fall off with a long exponential tail.  The virus incubates in the victim’s body and proliferates until 10 days after exposure when the viral load begins to decline in response to the body’s defenses.  Those with a low overall viral load may never see a high enough load to experience any symptoms or request testing.  About 10% of those exposed and get tested, typically around day 5, test positive (the current US weekly positivity rate).  About half of these never develop any symptoms but carry a high enough viral load to infect others for about 10 days after test or 15 days after exposure.  Half of those who test positive will usually experience some symptoms.  Most will stay home and treat themselves with medical guidance.  Some 6% of all positives will get sick enough to go to the hospital – although this has dropped recently to near 3%.  The steady drop since August is due to more kids and young adults being positive not requiring hospitalization, but it could also be due to overcrowding of hospital systems in certain regions like Los Angeles and Arizona.  About 1.5% of all those that tested positive will ultimately die in an average of 14 days from testing and 19 days from exposure.  As noted above, these deaths could take up to 8 weeks to get reported and counted.    

Thus when President Biden is sworn in on Jan 20th there will be:

1.     Deaths that have already occurred before Jan 20th that will get reported over the following 8 weeks (35k). 

2.     There will be a percentage of the 3.4M cases confirmed in the period before Jan 20th that will progress to hospitalizations, ICUs, and deaths that no one will be able to save.  The full accounting will take another eight weeks (69k).

3.     Alternatively, by the end of March the excess death report from the CDC will provide a measure of all deaths to Jan 20th and a portion of deaths to Feb 3rd that should be attributed to Trump’s policies and actions that President Biden could not reverse (140k). 

Whether using the case classification method or the excess death certificate method – the conclusion will be that more than half a million Americans died of COVID-19 under Trump’s watch that no one else could have saved.  Some might argue that every country suffered from the same devastating COVID-19 pandemic – it’s not Trump’s fault.  However, if Trump performed as well as the average government around the world and experienced the same average fatality per capita, only 71k Americans would have died by Jan 20th.  Trump’s gross mismanagement of the pandemic will be a large part of his legacy. 

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

COVID-19 Infection and Mortality Rates as a Function of Age and Gender

Image
With over 2.4 million COVID-19 cases and over 160,000 deaths globally, there is a lot of data that can be analyzed to better understand this virus as a function of age, co-morbidities, medical history (such as prior exposure to coronaviruses like SARS, and other vaccines like BCG), etc.   The two important factors that have been noted since the early days of this pandemic are age and gender and they continue to be the most important factors.   We look at the age and gender dependencies with the best single data set provided by the Spanish Health Department containing over 200,000 cases (or 0.4% of the total population) and over 20,000 deaths.   Spain has tested over 2.0% of its population which while short of a comprehensive sample does begin to give us some ideas about how the disease has affected the entire country.   We look at the probability of a random person acquiring the disease as a function of age.   We know that this sample is not truly random no...
Read more

COVID-19 is now officially a Pandemic

The WHO after many weeks of dithering has finally declared COVID-19 a pandemic.   Most scientists and healthcare professionals already had been treating it as such anyway.   Scientific advisers to Chancellor Merkel warned her that as many as 2/3 of all Germans may contract the coronavirus and she needed to attack it seriously and immediately as a major pandemic.   The US, as many had urged for weeks, is finally ramping up testing and found 313 new cases today – more than the cumulative total for weeks up to March 5 th .   The stock market took another major tumble today with the Dow now down more than 20% - forecasting a recession is coming to the US.   (These forecasts are sometimes scoffed at since the Dow has forecast 9 of the past 5 recessions.)   Is the world ending?   Is there any good news? I think the risks are many and they are far more likely than optimistic scenarios painted by Trump, but there are some signs that the world may av...
Read more

Pre-Thanksgiving Dip in COVID-19 Cases

Image
COVID-19 cases in the USA have shown a sharp decrease over the last 8 days causing the 7-day rolling average to peak and rollover (see figure below – red squares).   The question is whether this is measuring a real lasting phenomenon – perhaps attributable to local COVID-19 fires burning out, or to mitigation factors taking hold, or to some temporary factor associated with the Thanksgiving holiday.   The answer is probably a combination of all three that will ultimately be overwhelmed by an increase in Thanksgiving transmission. Some COVID-19 outbreaks have burned so strongly and for so long (3-4 months) that local “herd immunity” may be acting as a retardant to the fire.   For example, in North Dakota (ND) 10.3% of the population has now been confirmed infected (see table below).   State Confirmed Testing Est. Pop Deaths Death per Fatality   Infection % Positive % ...
Read more